Menu

Starters

Handmade Potato Onion Pierogis

Five in house made Polish pierogis served with polish cabbage, sour cream, homemade beet horseradish, and garnished with dill

Pine Island Blooming Onion

In house battered blooming onion served with a side of chipotle aioli

Amsterdam Authentic Bitterballen

Famous Dutch mini croquettes filled with a homemade sirloin bechamel filling and a side of Dijon mustard

Applewood Bacon Wrapped Scallops

Five applewood bacon wrapped scallops served over arugula and topped with a horseradish cream sauce

Chicken Tenders

4 in house made chicken tenders served with a side of hot honey mustard

Buffalo Wings

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Your choice of Plain/ Mild/Hot/Honey Garlic/BBQ/Sweet Thai Chili. Served with homemade buttermilk blue cheese or ranch dressing, carrots & celery

Mozzarella Sticks

5 mozzarella sticks served with a side of in house made marinara sauce

Homemade Potato Pancakes

Served with sour cream and homemade Warwick apple sauce

Giant 10 oz. Imported Bavarian Pretzel

Imported from Munich and served with honey mustard and homemade horseradish cream sauce.  Add: Cheese Sauce +$

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion

Salads

ADD PROTEIN (additional charge): Grilled Chicken, Breaded Chicken, Scottish Salmon

DRESSING CHOICES: Ranch, Russian, Balsamic, Honey Mustard, Buttermilk Blue Cheese, Apple Cider Vinaigrette

Hudson Valley Chatham Farm Wedge

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Baby iceberg lettuce topped with blue cheese crumbles, smoked apple wood bacon, heirloom grape tomatoes, scallions, and our homemade buttermilk blue cheese dressing

Burrata Mozzarella

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

In house made burrata served with charred cherry tomatoes, arugula, and topped with roasted garlic olive oil and smoked sea salt

Vanderhaus Salad

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Mixed greens served with cucumber, heirloom grape tomatoes, red onion, carrot, and your choice of dressing

The Finger Lakes Salad

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Mixed greens tossed with organic strawberries, blueberries, grapes, homemade candied walnuts, blue cheese crumbles, and our homemade apple cider vinaigrette

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Soups

Daily Soup du Jour

Ask server for details

Loaded Farmers Potato Leek Soup

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Topped with applewood smoked bacon, scallions, and shredded Cabot cheddar cheese

Pine Island Onion Soup Gratinee

Homemade French onion soup made with local black dirt onions, topped with homemade onion crostini, and gruyere cheese

Burgers, Sandwiches & More

Gluten Free Buns or Sub French Fries for a Side Salad available for additional charge.

EXTRA TOPPINGS (additional charge):
Apple-wood Smoked Bacon, Cheese (Cheddar, Gruyere, Mozzarella, blue cheese crumbles) or Crispy Fried Onions

Gluten Free Toppings: Caramelized Onions and Fried Egg

Vanderhaus Burger

Lowland Farm grass fed beef burger served on a brioche bun topped with applewood smoked bacon, caramelized onions, gruyere cheese sauce, fried onions, and served with a side of Gurda farms in house cut French fries

Smoked Prime Rib Dip

Smoked prime rib served on a brioche bun topped with onion jam, smoked gouda, and a whiskey au jus, served with in house made Gurda farms French fries

Farmers Country Fried Chicken Sandwich

Hand-breaded chicken cutlet served on a brioche bun topped lettuce, tomato, onion, creole aioli, and served with a side of Gurda farms in house cut French fries, and pickles

Mac & Cheese Your Way

Belgian mac and cheese
Add pulled pork +$
Add buffalo chicken +$

House Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich

Apple & cherry wood smoked pulled pork tossed in our homemade BBQ sauce topped with pickled red onions, served on a brioche bun with a side of coleslaw and Gurda farms in house cut French fries

Crab Cake Sandwich

In house made crab cake served on a brioche topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and a chive mustard sauce served with Gurda farms in house cut French fries

best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion

Jolly Onion Classics

World Famous Jager Schnitzel

Thinly pounded pork loin breaded and topped with our homemade hunter mushroom sauce, served with red cabbage, and home fries

Swedish Meatball Platter

House blend sirloin meatballs served with sour cream gravy, mashed potatoes, red cabbage and apples, and a side of imported lingonberry

Baltic Farmers Platter

Artisanal Locally Smoked Kielbasa, Kasseler smoked pork loin, two polish pierogis, polish braised cabbage with pork, and home fries

Munich Wurst Platter

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Artisanal local Bratwurst, Smoked Sausage, Vienna Wurst, sauerkraut, served with home fries, and grain mustard

best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion

Entrees

Chicken Marsala

In house breaded chicken topped with marsala sauce served with choice of roasted potatoes or linguini

Pan Roasted Chicken

Fresh chicken breast pan roasted in garlic butter served over a creamy orzo with spinach and sun-dried tomatoes

New York Strip Steak

Dakota Ranch Angus Strip 16oz. cut served with roasted potatoes and creamed spinach, topped with red wine braised onions

Filet Mignon

8oz filet mignon served with charred broccolini and roasted potatoes with a bourbon peppercorn sauce

Lemon Butter Salmon

Scottish Faroe Island Wild Salmon topped with a lobster beurre blanc sauce served over mashed potatoes and asparagus

Shrimp Scampi

Alaskan shrimp served over linguini topped with our house scampi sauce

New Bedford Pan Seared Scallops

5 wild caught scallops served over parmesan risotto topped with a brown butter sauce

Black Forest Veal Schnitzel

Thinly pounded fried veal cutlet with black forest ham, melted gruyere cheese served with home fries, red cabbage and apples, and a creamy white mushroom sauce

Wild Rice Harvest Veggie Bowl (Vegan)

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Wild Rice sautéed with organic spinach, asparagus tips, leeks, wild mushrooms, chickpeas, red pepper, roasted garlic, and EVOO

Penne ala Vodka

Penne pasta served in a creamy vodka tomato sauce garnished with parmesan cheese
Add: Chicken Grilled or Breaded +$
Add Applewood Smoked Bacon +$
*Gluten Free Pasta +$

best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion

Side Dishes

Mashed potato

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Home Fries

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Sauerkraut

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

French Fries

Creamed Spinach

Bavarian Red Cabbage

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Minnesota Wild Rice

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Homemade Spätzle Noodles

Asparagus with Garlic Butter

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion

Polish Braised Cabbage with Pork

best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
best restaurant warwick ny pine island the jolly onion

Kid's Menu

Burger and Fries

Hamburger served on a bun with french-fries, apple sauce, and pickles
Add cheese for additional charge

Crispy Pork Chop

Served with French fries and apple sauce

Chicken Tenders

Served with French Fries and apple sauce

Baked Mac n Cheese

Homemade mac and cheese served in our creamy cheese sauce

Kids Pasta

With butter or tomato sauce – Add meatballs for additional amount.

bar warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
bar warwick ny pine island the jolly onion
bar warwick ny pine island the jolly onion

Desserts

European Apple Strudel

Topped with caramel drizzle and served with a side of whipped cream. Add Ice Cream +$

Carrot Cake

Drizzled with caramel and served with a side of whipped cream

Classic Dutch Dame Blanche Sundae

Vanilla ice cream and house made chocolate sauce layered and topped with whipped cream and a cannoli chip

New York Style Cheesecake

Drizzled with caramel and served with a side of whipped cream

Chocolate Mousse Torte

Served with whipped cream and our house made chocolate sauce

Strawberry Belgian Waffle

Belgian waffle topped with fresh strawberries, caramel drizzle, and served with a side of whipped cream. Your choice of vanilla or chocolate ice cream.

Special Nights

See our SPECIALS PAGE for featured Events.

Call 845-981-7272 for more info on any of our Special Nights.

See Daily Specials on our Facebook Page